Top Places To Rent In St. Marys, GA: A Comprehensive Guide

Audreanne Maggio DVM 20 Jun 2025

When you're searching for places to rent in St. Marys, GA, it's important to consider a variety of factors that make this charming coastal town a perfect destination for renters. Whether you're relocating for work, retirement, or simply looking for a vacation spot, St. Marys offers a unique blend of southern charm, natural beauty, and accessibility to nearby attractions like Cumberland Island. This article will explore the top rental options available in the area, helping you find the perfect home that suits your needs.

St. Marys, Georgia, often referred to as the "Gateway to Cumberland Island," is a hidden gem nestled in the southeastern corner of the state. Known for its warm climate, historic sites, and proximity to nature, it has become an increasingly popular location for both long-term residents and vacationers alike. As the demand for rentals continues to grow, so does the variety of housing options available.

This guide will provide you with detailed insights into the best places to rent in St. Marys, GA, including apartments, houses, and vacation rentals. We'll also explore the neighborhoods, amenities, and factors to consider when making your decision. By the end of this article, you'll have a clear understanding of what St. Marys has to offer and how to find your ideal rental property.

Overview of St. Marys, GA
Top Neighborhoods to Rent in St. Marys
Types of Rentals Available in St. Marys
Understanding Rental Costs in St. Marys
Key Amenities and Features to Look For
Current Market Trends
Tips for Finding the Best Rental
Vacation Rentals in St. Marys
Long-Term Rentals in St. Marys
Conclusion

Overview of St. Marys, GA

History and Culture

St. Marys, Georgia, is steeped in history and culture, making it a fascinating place to live or visit. Established in the late 18th century, this town has witnessed significant historical events, including its role during the Civil War. Today, it boasts a vibrant community that celebrates its heritage through annual festivals, museums, and historic sites. The town's cultural diversity and friendly atmosphere create a welcoming environment for new residents.

Geography and Climate

Located near the Georgia-Florida border, St. Marys enjoys a subtropical climate with mild winters and warm summers. The town's proximity to the Atlantic Ocean and numerous waterways provides residents with breathtaking views and opportunities for water-based activities. Whether you're into fishing, boating, or simply enjoying the beach, St. Marys offers plenty of natural beauty to explore.

Proximity to Cumberland Island

One of the most significant attractions near St. Marys is Cumberland Island National Seashore. This pristine island offers a sanctuary for wildlife and a peaceful retreat for visitors. Renting a place in St. Marys puts you within easy reach of this natural wonder, making it an ideal location for nature lovers and adventurers alike.

Top Neighborhoods to Rent in St. Marys

Historic Downtown

The historic downtown area of St. Marys is a popular choice for renters who appreciate character and charm. This neighborhood is filled with beautifully restored homes, boutique shops, and local eateries. Living here gives you easy access to cultural events, community gatherings, and the town's rich history.

Waterfront Communities

If you're looking for a rental with water views, consider the waterfront communities in St. Marys. These areas offer stunning vistas of the Intracoastal Waterway and the nearby marshlands. Many properties come with private docks, perfect for those who enjoy boating and fishing.

Residential Suburbs

For families or individuals seeking a quieter, more suburban lifestyle, St. Marys has several residential neighborhoods to choose from. These areas provide a peaceful environment with well-maintained streets and parks, making them ideal for raising children or enjoying a relaxing lifestyle.

Types of Rentals Available in St. Marys

Apartment Rentals

For those seeking more affordable options, apartment rentals in St. Marys are a great choice. These properties often come with modern amenities, such as swimming pools, fitness centers, and community spaces. Apartments are ideal for singles or couples looking for convenience and affordability.

Single-Family Homes

Single-family homes offer more space and privacy, making them perfect for families or those who need additional living areas. Many of these homes feature spacious yards, multiple bedrooms, and updated kitchens, providing a comfortable and inviting atmosphere.

Vacation Homes

Vacation rentals in St. Marys cater to travelers and temporary residents who want to experience the best of what the area has to offer. These homes often come fully furnished and equipped with luxury features, ensuring a memorable stay.

Understanding Rental Costs in St. Marys

Average Rent Prices

Rental prices in St. Marys vary depending on the type of property and its location. Apartments typically range from $800 to $1,500 per month, while single-family homes can cost anywhere from $1,200 to $3,000 per month. Vacation rentals may be priced higher, especially during peak tourist seasons.

Factors Affecting Costs

Several factors influence rental costs in St. Marys, including proximity to the waterfront, property size, and amenities offered. Additionally, demand tends to increase during the summer months and holiday seasons, driving prices up.

Key Amenities and Features to Look For

Proximity to Cumberland Island Ferry
Access to Local Parks and Nature Trails
Modern Kitchen Appliances
High-Speed Internet Connectivity
Pet-Friendly Policies

Current Market Trends

Increasing Demand for Rentals

As more people discover the charm of St. Marys, the demand for rental properties continues to rise. This trend is driven by retirees, remote workers, and tourists who appreciate the town's relaxed lifestyle and natural beauty.

Impact of Tourism

The tourism industry plays a significant role in shaping the rental market in St. Marys. With Cumberland Island and other attractions drawing visitors year-round, there is a steady demand for short-term rentals, which has influenced the overall housing market.

Tips for Finding the Best Rental

Research Thoroughly

Before committing to a rental, conduct thorough research on the property, neighborhood, and landlord. Check reviews, visit the location if possible, and ensure all terms of the lease agreement are clear and satisfactory.

Consider Long-Term vs. Short-Term

Decide whether you need a long-term or short-term rental based on your needs and circumstances. Long-term rentals offer stability, while short-term options provide flexibility.

Ask About Additional Fees

Be sure to inquire about any additional fees, such as security deposits, pet fees, or utility costs. These can significantly impact your overall budget.

Vacation Rentals in St. Marys

Popular Vacation Rental Areas

Some of the most popular vacation rental areas in St. Marys include the waterfront communities and neighborhoods close to Cumberland Island. These properties often come with stunning views and easy access to local attractions.

Booking Platforms

Several reputable platforms, such as Airbnb and Vrbo, offer a wide selection of vacation rentals in St. Marys. These platforms provide detailed property descriptions, customer reviews, and secure booking processes.

Long-Term Rentals in St. Marys

Benefits of Long-Term Rentals

Long-term rentals in St. Marys offer several benefits, including stability, lower costs compared to short-term stays, and the opportunity to become part of the local community. Many landlords offer incentives for long-term tenants, such as discounted rent or flexible lease terms.

Challenges and Considerations

When considering a long-term rental, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons. Factors such as lease length, maintenance responsibilities, and potential rent increases should all be taken into account before signing a lease agreement.

Conclusion

St. Marys, GA, offers a diverse range of rental options for those looking to live or vacation in this picturesque town. From charming historic homes to luxurious vacation rentals, there's something for everyone in St. Marys. By understanding the market trends, considering your needs, and conducting thorough research, you can find the perfect place to call home.

We encourage you to explore the various neighborhoods and rental types available in St. Marys. Whether you're planning a short-term stay or a long-term move, this town has much to offer. Don't forget to share your thoughts in the comments section below or explore other articles on our website for more insights into the area. Happy renting!

Data Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, National Park Service, Local Real Estate Listings

Best Places to Live Compare cost of living, crime, cities, schools

St Marys Authentic idsdeutschland.de

Riverview Hotel St. Marys Explore

True Celebs